The new props have a LOT more surface area then the old prop you are probably using.... 3600rpms seems really low. I run a 13x12 Acme and it works really well. I also have a 14x14 antique that is my spare. Works great but you can tell by looking at them that the Acme (even at an inch smaller) has more surface area. I'm a fan of 3-blades (because that's what the experts at OJ and Acme recommended to me.) I'm sure someone will be on here pretty quickly to tell you that they prefer 4-blades. I'd call Acme or OJ or Nettles and ask them for a recomendation.... They know best.
Former owner of a 1987 Supra Saltare. Current owner of a Malibu 23LSV.